Content creators and reel makers cannot claim the protection the Supreme Court extended to journalists covering protests against Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar, the Delhi Police has told the Court. The police made the argument in an affidavit, Bar and Bench reported.
On October 11, the Court had directed that journalists “shall not be hindered in discharge of their professional duties in any manner whatsoever.”
“The said direction protects journalists in the discharge of their professional duties and does not, and was not intended to, exempt the so-called reel-makers and social media influencers or unruly elements from the operation of the general law or from compliance with the lawful directions of the Law Enforcement Agencies at the site of a prohibited assembly,” the affidavit said.
The affidavit responds to petitions by the Network of Women in Media, India, the Free Speech Collective, the Delhi Union of Journalists, the Kerala Union of Working Journalists and others. They argue that the police violated the October 11 order by detaining and obstructing journalists.
The Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) organised the protests. It wants Kumar to resign over alleged irregularities in the special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.
Who counts as a journalist?
“In the present era of evolving digital media, several individuals, whether creative or otherwise, make reels, upload them and commercially exploit the content created by them. While there can be no objection to such activities, the question as to whether such reel-makers can be elevated to the status of journalists or reporters is yet to be determined,” the affidavit said.
The police asked the Court to separate journalists who report facts neutrally from people who record events for content. It proposed a test: “The predominant intent behind the activity may be the decisive factor.” It also said some protesters carried cameras and microphones and falsely claimed to be journalists.
The affidavit accepts that freelancers, independent media persons, citizens and YouTubers have a constitutional right to gather and publish news. It says they don’t lose this right for lacking accreditation from the Press Information Bureau (PIB), a press card or a job at a recognised news organisation. They must still follow police directions, “as is the case with every other citizen.”
Why it matters
- Officers would decide who a journalist is: Under the police’s test, an officer at a barricade would have to judge a person’s “predominant intent” on the spot. The officer’s judgment would then decide whether the Court’s protection applies.
- The people most affected lack press cards: At the October protests, the detentions fell mostly on digital journalists and YouTubers without PIB cards. The police’s position would leave the same group exposed at the next protest.
- The ruling will apply beyond these protests: The Court has said it will decide what protection different kinds of journalists get. That decision will govern how police treat freelancers, independent journalists and creators at future protests across the country.
What happened at the protests?
On October 10 and 11, police allegedly let PIB-accredited reporters through. They turned back or detained digital journalists and YouTubers who lacked PIB cards. The Committee to Protect Journalists reported that 37 journalists were detained, including 35 in Delhi.
What has the Court said?
At an October 15 hearing, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta told the Court, “We do not know who is a reel maker, who is an independent journalist.”
Justice Joymalya Bagchi said the Court will examine whether accredited journalists, freelancers, independent journalists and influencers need different levels of protection. He said there “will be layers of protection.”
How did the police respond to specific allegations?
The police denied obstructing any journalist and asked the Court to dismiss the petitions.
- Sexual harassment complaints: Three journalists accused an officer of sexual harassment during an incident on October 3. The police said two didn’t want to pursue their complaints and the third didn’t join the inquiry. It said CCTV footage showed no harassment, and it has closed all three complaints.
- The Caravan’s Ryan Thomas: The police denied assaulting or detaining him on October 11. It said it “merely removed” him from the site during crowd control.
- Paranjoy Guha Thakurta: The police denied illegally detaining him. It cited his own statement that officers drove him around for about 20 minutes and released him half a kilometre away.
- Shyam Meera Singh: The police questioned whether he was reporting or protesting. It said he shouted slogans, “which a journalist would never indulge in.”
- Other reporters: The police said it released a reporter from The Hindu and three Indian Express reporters once it recognised their credentials. It said a Deputy Commissioner of Police expressed regret to Peek TV’s reporters.
- Equipment: The police said it seized nothing from journalists.
Also Read:
- Live Tracker: Censorship and digital developments from the CJP protests at Jantar Mantar
- Supreme Court Orders Unhindered Internet Access in Delhi
- Meta AI glasses being used for police surveillance in Delhi
The post Reel makers don’t get journalists’ protection at protests, Delhi Police tells Supreme Court appeared first on MEDIANAMA.





